Calcium phosphate-hybridized tendon graft to enhance tendon-bone healing two years after ACL reconstruction in goats
© Mutsuzaki and Sakane; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2011
Received: 7 April 2011
Accepted: 14 December 2011
Published: 14 December 2011
We developed a novel technique to improve tendon-bone attachment by hybridizing calcium phosphate (CaP) with a tendon graft using an alternate soaking process. However, the long-term result with regard to the interface between the tendon graft and the bone is unclear.
We analyzed bone tunnel enlargement by computed tomography and histological observation of the interface and the tendon graft with and without the CaP hybridization 2 years after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction in goats using EndoButton and the postscrew technique (CaP, n = 4; control, n = 4).
The tibial bone tunnel enlargement rates in the CaP group were lower than those in the control group (p < 0.05). In the CaP group, in the femoral and tibial bone tunnels at the anterior and posterior of the joint aperture site, direct insertion-like formation that contained a cartilage layer without tidemarks was more observed at the tendon-bone interface than in the control group (p < 0.05). Moreover, the gap area between the tendon graft and the bone was more observed at the femoral bone tunnel of the joint aperture site in the control group than in the CaP group (p < 0.05). The maturation of the tendon grafts determined using the ligament tissue maturation index was similar in both groups.
The CaP-hybridized tendon graft enhanced the tendon-bone healing 2 years after ACL reconstruction in goats. The use of CaP-hybridized tendon grafts can reduce the bone tunnel enlargement and gap area associated with the direct insertion-like formation in the interface near the joint.
KeywordsACL reconstruction tendon-bone healing calcium phosphate hybridization direct insertion bone tunnel enlargement
The anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) is the most frequently injured ligament in the knee. Surgical reconstruction using a replacement graft is the preferred method of treatment. A semitendinosus-gracilis (STG) tendon graft, the so-called soft tissue graft, is commonly used [1, 2]. However, the STG tendon graft requires soft-tissue-to-bone healing within both bone tunnels. Grana et al.  observed indirect bonding with fibrous tissue between a hamstring tendon autograft and bone tunnels in a rabbit ACL reconstruction model. The indirect bonding formation at the interface is similar to that observed after a long period . Many studies attempted to improve the healing of tendon to bone with different therapeutic modalities including application of periosteum augmentation, bone morphogenetic protein, calcium-phosphate cement, granulocyte colony-stimulating factor, gene transfer, and so on [5–11]. We developed a novel technique to improve tendon-bone attachment by hybridizing calcium phosphate (CaP) with tendons using an alternate soaking process . Using the CaP-hybridized tendon, we observed a scarless direct bonding area between the tendon graft and the bone without inflammation two to three weeks after ACL reconstruction in rabbits [13, 14], which was also observed in goats . The CaP-hybridized tendon graft reduced bone tunnel enlargement in the femoral side 6 months after ACL reconstruction in goats . Moreover, the anterior-posterior translations in the reconstructed knees in the CaP group were shorter and the corresponding in situ forces were greater than those in the control group at full extension and 60° of knee flexion 1 year after the ACL reconstruction in goats . The new bone formation at the bone tunnel and cartilage layer formation at the tendon-bone interface near the joint in the CaP group were more observed than those in the control group . Commonly, a minimum of two years of follow-up after ACL reconstruction is recommended in order to evaluate the clinical results. However, the long-term effect of the CaP-hybridized tendon after ACL reconstruction in animal experiments is unclear. To clarify this issue, we used a goat model of ACL reconstruction, because long-term studies of goat knees have shown the effective restoration of knee stability after ACL reconstruction [18, 19].
We considered that an appropriate mechanical stress at the interface after bonding between the tendon graft and the bone, and a prerequisite firm anchoring may promote direct insertion-like formation at the tendon-bone interface and the maturation of the tendon graft [13–17]. Therefore, we hypothesized that cartilaginous anchoring formation between the tendon graft and the bone is more mature, and both the bone tunnel enlargement and the percentage of the gap area at the interface that is loosening 2 years after ACL reconstruction are smaller when using the CaP hybridization method than when using the conventional method, because the anchoring formation in the CaP group (direct bonding and cartilaginous anchoring) is different from that in the control group (fibrous bonding) from 2 weeks to 1 year after the operation [13–17]. Moreover, the graft in the CaP group may be more mature than that in the control group, because of its anchoring formation associated with an appropriate mechanical stress.
The objective of this study was to analyze bone tunnel enlargement by computed tomography (CT) and histological observation of the interface and the tendon graft in the group with the CaP-hybridized tendon graft and in the group with untreated tendon graft 2 years after ACL reconstruction using a goat model.
Materials and methods
CaP hybridization method
Eight skeletally mature female Saanen breed goats (50-70 kg) were used in this study. The goats were maintained in accordance with the guidelines of the Ethical Committee of the Biomaterial Center of the National Institute for Materials Science and the National Institutes of Health guidelines for the care and use of laboratory animals (NIH Pub. No. 85-23 Rev. 1985).
All the surgical procedures were performed under sterile conditions with the animals under general anesthesia. On the right knee, an anterior lateral skin incision was made. The ACL was then completely transected and the gross anterior subluxation of the tibia was confirmed by manual examination. We drilled using a Kirschner wire from the anteromedial surface of the proximal tibia to the tibial insertion of the ACL. Then we drilled femoral side straightly with the knee positioned in 45° flexion to ensure consistency of surgical technique. The bone tunnel was reamed using a 5.5-mm-diameter canulated drill, resulting in the bone tunnel in the femoral side opening anterior of the femoral insertion. The length of the tunnel was at least 20 mm.
The graft described above was passed through the femoral and tibial tunnels and fixed to the anteromedial surface of the tibia with 20 N as the initial tension using a 4.5-mm-diameter cortex screw (MEIRA Corporation, Nagoya, Japan) [15–17].
Ex vivo CT
The four frozen specimens of goats from each group were used for CT (Brilliance CT 64, Philips, Amsterdam, Netherlands) to assess femoral and tibial bone tunnels. The CT (voltage: 120 kV, current: 230 mA) in the full extension knee position was supervised and the obtained CT images were analyzed by a single radiologist. A standard protocol was used consistently throughout the study. Initial volume acquisition was with 0.9 mm slices from 30 mm above the femoral tunnel to 30 mm below the tibial tunnel. Using the work station of Virtual Place Lexus (AZE Ltd., Tokyo, Japan), three-dimensional images were reconstructed. Axial images of the femoral and tibial bone tunnels were obtained using the reconstructed three-dimensional images. We measured the tunnel cross-sectional area (CSA) of the femur and tibia at the main joint aperture site using the axial images of the femoral and tibial bone tunnels. The rate of increase in tunnel CSA was calculated using the following formula: CSA increase rate (%) = (CSA at 2 years - Initial CSA) × 100/Initial CSA . Initial CSA is calculated on the basis of the diameter of the reamer.
The ligament tissue maturation index (LTMI) of Murray et al.  was used to evaluate the maturation of tendon grafts according to the following 3 criteria:  cellular aspects including cell density, nuclear shape, and orientation;  extracellular matrix characteristics, such as crimp; and  vascular features including blood vessel density and maturity (total score, 28 points).
The bone tunnel enlargement data and histological analysis of the two groups were compared using Student's t-test at a p < 0.05 significance value. To compare the histological difference between the CaP and control groups, Mann-Whitney's U test was used at a p < 0.05 significance value.
Ex vivo CT
Histological observation (cartilage layer formation)
Femur (N = 4)
Tibia (N = 4)
CaP group (n = 4)
Control (n = 4)
Histological observation (red stained area by Safranin-O staining in cartilage layer at interface)
CaP group (n = 4)
0.15 ± 0.29
0.08 ± 0.16
2.65 ± 3.15
0.56 ± 0.68
1.45 ± 0.76
0.35 ± 0.16
1.15 ± 1.38
0.22 ± 0.18
Control (n = 4)
0.42 ± 0.85
0.09 ± 0.17
0.56 ± 0.54
0.21 ± 0.24
0.28 ± 0.55
0.08 ± 0.16
Histological observation (gap area at interface)
N = 4
N = 4
gap area rate: AV ± SD %
gap area rate: AV ± SD %
CaP group (n = 4)
4.3 ± 8.7% *
4.5 ± 9.0%
Control (n = 4)
42.4 ± 20.4%
13.0 ± 13.4%
14.4 ± 18.7%
In the CaP group, the gap area at the interface was small at the anterior surface of the tibial bone tunnel in none of the specimens, at the posterior surface of the tibial bone tunnel in none of the specimens, at the anterior surfaces of the femoral bone tunnel in 1 specimen, and at the posterior surface of the femoral bone tunnel in 1 specimen. The gap area rates were 0% in the anterior tibial bone tunnel, 0% in the posterior tibial bone tunnel, 4.3 ± 8.7% in the anterior femoral bone tunnel, and 4.5 ± 9.0% in the posterior femoral bone tunnel. The gap area rate in the anterior femoral bone tunnel in the CaP group was significantly smaller than that in the control group (p = 0.0069).
We found direct insertion-like formation at the interface in the CaP group 2 years after ACL reconstruction. However, the structure was different from a normal insertion structure because it lacked tidemarks. The cartilage layer in the femoral and tibial bone tunnels at the anterior and posterior of the aperture site was more prominent between the tendon graft and the bone in the CaP group than in the control group. Mechanical load has significant effects on the formation, degradation, regeneration, and tissue composition of tendons in vitro and in vivo [21–25]. Yamakado et al.  demonstrated the regeneration of tendon-bone junctions at the entrance of bone tunnels after extensor tendons were grafted extra-articularly. They suggested that tension and/or compression enhances the healing of tendon-bone junctions and chondroid formation. In the CaP method, scarless direct bonding, which is due to the fact that the bonelike microstructure contains low-crystalline apatite and type I collagen, and reduction of inflammation are achieved in the early postoperative phase [13–15]. Then, the interface becomes a cartilaginous insertion 6 months after ACL reconstruction . Moreover, the in situ force in the tendon graft is greater in the CaP method than in the conventional method 1 year after ACL reconstruction . The interface with a CaP-hybridized tendon graft after direct bonding can react to tension and/or compression. The mechanical environment (tensile and/or compressive force) in this direct bonding probably further may promote the differentiation of the interface zone to a cartilage layer. Therefore, cartilaginous direct insertion-like formation can be realized 2 years after ACL reconstruction in the CaP group. However, we were unable to regenerate tidemarks, because the tendon-bone alignment in the reconstructed knee differs from that in the knee with normal ACL insertion. ACL insertion consists of four distinguishable tissue layers in transition, that is, ligaments, fibrocartilage, mineralized fibrocartilage, and bone [27, 28]. The fibrocartilage and mineralized cartilage function as a stress or shock absorber by reducing the stiffness gradient between the ligament and the bone [29, 30]. Reconstructing the highly specialized structure of cartilaginous insertion is necessary to reduce the transverse contraction of the ligament during tensile loading, which therefore acts as a stretching brake . Joint aperture site healing with two distinguishable cartilaginous insertion layers (direct insertion-like formation) in the CaP group can neutralize graft motion within the tunnel. On the other hand, in the control group, mainly fibrous tissue intervention was observed at the interface between the tendon graft and the bone tunnel. A prolonged instability of the interface formed using an untreated tendon graft in the early postoperative period could lead to fibrous insertion formation owing to micromotion and inflammation at the interface for a long time. Shear stress at the interface associated with the bungee effect (longitudinal micromotion) , rotational micromotion, and transverse micromotion (windshield wiper effect) promotes fibrous insertion formation (Sharpey's fibers) in the control group, as similarly previously reported [3, 13].
Bone tunnel enlargement in the CaP group was lesser in both the femoral and tibial bone tunnels than that in the control group. The possible etiologies for tunnel widening include synovial fluid cytokines, graft-tunnel micromotion, and inflammatory mediators. Synovial fluid influx into a bone tunnel may also affect healing. Berg et al.  studied the healing of empty bone tunnels in rabbit knees and found rapid bone formation at the extra-articular exit of a femoral tunnel, whereas bone formation was delayed at the intra-articular exit of the tunnel. They postulated that synovial fluid cytokines delay the healing of the intra-articular exit of the tunnel. Moreover, enlargement of the articular end of the bone tunnels is a common problem in ACL reconstruction , because the graft-tunnel motion can be greater at the tunnel aperture site than at the extra-articular end of the tunnel for grafts fixed by suspensory fixation. In the control group, a marked tunnel enlargement was observed by CT, and a histologically large gap area with synovial tissue covering the tendon graft and bone tunnel surface was also observed. Therefore, the continued micromotion at the interface can lead to bone tunnel enlargement not only on the femoral side but also on the tibial side when using untreated tendon grafts in our animal experiment 2 years after the operation. Moreover, bone tunnel enlargement on the femoral side 6 months after ACL reconstruction  could increase the gap area at the interface on the femoral side 2 years after the operation, because of micromotion and joint fluid. Synovial fluid pumping with cytokines caused by graft motion in the bone tunnel can promote synovial membrane formation on the tendon graft and bone tunnel surface. These phenomena may account for the loosening at the interface and knee instability in the control group. On the other hand, in the CaP group, the cartilage layer in the interface on the joint aperture site side can prevent the influx of synovial fluid and absorb the graft-tunnel motion. Therefore, bone tunnel enlargement was lesser and the gap area was smaller in the CaP group than in the control group.
The enhanced tendon-bone healing in the CaP group did not result in the maturation of the tendon graft. We considered that firm anchoring would be important for the maturation of the tendon graft. The midsubstance of the graft prepared using the CaP-hybridization method may promote the recovery of mechanical strength owing to its effective load transfer through the tibia-graft-femur construct after anchoring 1 year after ACL reconstruction in goats . However, the maturation of the tendon graft in both groups was similar 2 years after ACL reconstruction. It may be difficult in terms of long-term results in animals to set appropriate mechanical conditions for ACL reconstruction by joint geometry.
Regarding the limitation of this study, since we did not perform mechanical analysis 2 years after ACL reconstruction, the mechanical strength in both groups is unclear in this study. Further study to clarify the mechanical properties of the tendon graft and to clarify the effect of mechanical stress on graft maturation is required. Examination of non-significant results of this study may be necessary to check for possible false negatives due to the small number of samples. If we use a larger number of specimens, a clearer significant difference may have appeared.
The CaP-hybridized tendon graft enhanced the tendon-bone healing 2 years after ACL reconstruction in goats. The CaP-hybridized tendon graft can reduce the bone tunnel enlargement and the gap area associated with the direct insertion-like formation in the interface at the joint aperture site.
The authors thank the Leading Project (LP) of the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology of Japan for financial support.
- Biau DJ, Katsahian S, Kartus J, Harilainen A, Feller JA, Sajovic M, Ejerhed L, Zaffagnini S, Röpke M, Nizard R: Patellar tendon versus hamstring tendon autografts for reconstructing the anterior cruciate ligament: a meta-analysis based on individual patient data. Am J Sports Med. 2009, 37: 2470-2478.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Taylor DC, DeBerardino TM, Nelson BJ, Duffey M, Tenuta J, Stoneman PD, Sturdivant RX, Mountcastle S: Patellar tendon versus hamstring tendon autografts for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a randomized controlled trial using similar femoral and tibial fixation methods. Am J Sports Med. 2009, 37: 1946-1957.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Grana WA, Egle DM, Mahnken R, Goodhart CW: An analysis of autograft fixation after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in a rabbit model. Am J Sports Med. 1994, 22: 344-351.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Nebelung W, Becker R, Urbach D, Röpke M, Roessner A: Histological findings of tendon-bone healing following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with hamstring grafts. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg. 2003, 123: 158-163.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Chen CH, Chen WJ, Shih CH, Yang CY, Liu SJ, Lin PY: Enveloping the tendon graft with periosteum to enhance tendon-bone healing in a bone tunnel: a biomechanical and histologic study in rabbits. Arthroscopy. 2003, 19: 290-296.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Hashimoto Y, Yoshida G, Toyoda H, Takaoka K: Generation of tendon-to-bone interface ''enthesis'' with use of recombinant BMP-2 in a rabbit model. J Orthop Res. 2007, 25: 1415-1424.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Rodeo SA, Suzuki K, Deng XH, Wozney J, Warren RF: Use of recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein-2 to enhance tendon healing in a bone tunnel. Am J Sports Med. 1999, 27: 476-488.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Huangfu X, Zhao J: Tendon-bone healing enhancement using injectable tricalcium phosphate in a dog anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction model. Arthroscopy. 2007, 23: 455-462.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Sasaki K, Kuroda R, Ishida K, Kubo S, Matsumoto T, Mifune Y, Kinoshita K, Tei K, Akisue T, Tabata Y, Kurosaka M: Enhancement of tendon-bone osteointegration of anterior cruciate ligament grafts using granulocyte colony-stimulating factor. Am J Sports Med. 2008, 36: 1519-1527.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Martinek V, Latterman C, Usas A, Abramowitch S, Woo SL, Fu FH, Huard J: Enhancement of tendon-bone integration of anterior cruciate ligament grafts with bone morphogenetic protein-2 gene transfer: a histological and biomechanical study. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2002, 84: 1123-1131.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Lattermann C, Zelle BA, Whalen JD, Baltzer AW, Robbins PD, Niyibizi C, Evans CH, Fu FH: Gene transfer to the tendon-bone insertion site. Knee Surg Sports Traum. 2004, 12: 510-515.Google Scholar
- Taguchi T, Kishida A, Akashi M: Apatite formation on/in hydrogel matrices using an alternate soaking process: II. Effect of swelling ratios of poly(vinyl alcohol) hydrogel matrices on apatite formation. J Biomater Sci Polym Ed. 1999, 10: 331-339.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Mutsuzaki H, Sakane M, Nakajima H, Ito A, Hattori S, Miyanaga Y, Ochiai N, Tanaka J: Calcium-phosphate-hybridized tendon directly promotes regeneration of tendon-bone insertion. J Biomed Mater Res. 2004, 70A: 319-327.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Mutsuzaki H, Sakane M, Ito A, Nakajima H, Hattori S, Miyanaga Y, Tanaka J, Ochiai N: The interaction between osteoclast-like cells and osteoblasts mediated by nanophase calcium phosphate-hybridized tendons. Biomaterials. 2005, 26: 1027-1034.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Mutsuzaki H, Sakane M, Hattori S, Kobayashi H, Ochiai N: Firm anchoring between calcium phosphate-hybridized tendon and bone for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in a goat model. Biomed Mater. 2009, 4: 045013.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Mutsuzaki H, Sakane M, Nakajima H, Ochiai N: Calcium phosphate-hybridized tendon graft to reduce bone tunnel enlargement after ACL reconstruction in goats. Knee. 2011.Google Scholar
- Mutsuzaki H, Sakane M, Fujie H, Hattori S, Kobayashi H, Ochiai N: Effect of calcium phosphate-hybridized tendon graft on biomechanical behavior in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in a goat model: novel technique for improving tendon-bone healing. Am J Sports Med. 2011, 39: 1059-1066.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Jackson DW, Grood ES, Goldstein JD, Rosen MA, Kurzweil PR, Cummings JF, Simon TM: A comparison of patellar tendon autograft and allograft used for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in the goat model. Am J Sports Med. 1993, 21: 176-185.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Ng GY, Oakes BW, Deacon OW, McLean ID, Lampard D: Biomechanics of patellar tendon autograft for reconstruction of anterior cruciate ligament in the goat: Three-year study. J Orthop Res. 1995, 13: 602-608.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Murray MM, Spindler KP, Ballard P, Welch TP, Zurakowski D, Nanney LB: Enhanced histologic repair in a central wound in the anterior cruciate ligament with a collagen-platelet-rich plasma scaffold. J Orthop Res. 2007, 25: 1007-1017.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Slack C, Flint MH, Thompson BM: The effect of tensional load on isolated embryonic chick tendons in organ culture. Connect Tissue Res. 1984, 12: 229-247.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Hannafin JA, Arnoczky SP, Hoonjan A, Torzilli PA: Effect of stress deprivation and cyclic tensile loading on the material and morphologic properties of canine flexor digitorum profundus tendon: an in vitro study. J Orthop Res. 1995, 13: 907-914.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Nabeshima Y, Grood ES, Sakurai A, Herman JH: Uniaxial tension inhibits tendon collagen degradation by collagenase in vitro. J Orthop Res. 1996, 14: 123-130.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Evanko SP, Vogel KG: Ploteoglycan synthesis in fetal tendon is differentially regulated by cyclic compression in vitro. Arch Biochem Biophys. 1993, 307: 153-164.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Giori NJ, Beaupre GSB, Carter DR: Cellular shape and pressure may mediate mechanical control of tissue composition in tendons. J Orthop Res. 1993, 11: 581-591.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Yamakado K, Kitaoka K, Yamada H, Hashiba K, Nakamura R, Tomita K: The influence of mechanical stress on graft healing in a bone tunnel. Arthroscopy. 2002, 18 (1): 82-90.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Benjamin M, Evans EJ, Copp L: The histology of tendon attachments to bone in man. J Anat. 1986, 149: 89-100.PubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Cooper RR, Misol S: Tendon and ligament insertion: a light and electron microscopic study. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1970, 52: 1-20.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Knese K-H, Biermann H: Osteogenesis in tendon and ligament insertions in the area of the original chondral apophyses. Z Zellforsch Mikrosk Anat. 1958, 49: 142-187.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Schneider H: Zur Struktur der Sehnenansatzzonen. Z Anat. 1956, 119: 431-456.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Höher J, Livesay GA, Ma CB, et al: Hamstring graft motion in the femoral bone tunnel when using titanium button/polyester tape fixation. Knee Surg Sports Traum. 1999, 7: 215-219.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Berg EE, Pollard ME, Kang Q: Intraarticular bone tunnel healing. Arthroscopy. 2001, 17: 189-195.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Rodeo SA, Kawamura S, Ma CB, Ma CB, Deng XH, Sussman PS, Hays P, Ying L: The effect of osteoclast activity on tendon-to-bone healing: an experimental study in rabbits. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2007, 89: 2250-2259.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.