Skip to main content

Table 10 Results of studies per outcome

From: Neuromuscular training to enhance sensorimotor and functional deficits in subjects with chronic ankle instability: A systematic review and best evidence synthesis

OUTCOME

DESCRIPTION

STUDIES

TIME EFFECT

GROUP EFFECT

BEST EVIDENCE SYNTHESIS (TIME)

BEST EVIDENCE SYNTHESIS (GROUP)

Static Postural Stability

S.I. for 8 conditions

     
 

Stable platform (E.O) AP

1 HR RCT

NO

NO

LENE

LENE

 

Stable platform (E.O) ML

1 HR RCT

NO

NO

LENE

LENE

 

Stable platform (E.C) AP

1 HR RCT

NO

NO

LENE

LENE

 

Stable platform (E.C) ML

1 HR RCT

NO

NO

LENE

LENE

 

Dynamic platform (E.O) AP

1 HR RCT

NO

NO

LENE

LENE

 

Dynamic platform (E.O) ML

1 HR RCT

NO

NO

LENE

LENE

 

Dynamic platform (E.C) AP

1 HR RCT

NO

NO

LENE

LENE

 

Dynamic platform (E.C) ML

1 HR RCT

NO

NO

LENE

LENE

 

MES for 8 conditions

     
 

Stable platform (E.O) AP

1 HR RCT

NO

NO

LENE

LENE

 

Stable platform (E.O) ML

1 HR RCT

NO

NO

LENE

LENE

 

Stable platform (E.C) AP

1 HR RCT

YES

YES

LEOE

LEOE

 

Stable platform (E.C) ML

1 HR RCT

YES

NO

LEOE

LENE

 

Dynamic platform (E.O) AP

1 HR RCT

NO

NO

LENE

LENE

 

Dynamic platform (E.O) ML

1 HR RCT

NO

NO

LENE

LENE

 

Dynamic platform (E.C) AP

1 HR RCT

YES

NO

LEOE

LENE

 

Dynamic platform (E.C) ML

1 HR RCT

YES

YES

LEOE

LEOE

 

Biodex Generated Stability Indices

     
 

Involved limb at level 2

1 HR RCT

YES

YES

LEOE

LEOE

 

Involved limb at level 6

1 HR RCT

YES

YES

LEOE

LEOE

 

COP Values

     
 

COP Area (E.O)

3 HR RCTS

YES, NO, NO

YES, NO, NO

CE

CE

 

COP M/L (E.O)

2 HR RCTS

NO, NO

NO, NO

MENE

MENE

 

COP A/P (E.O)

2 HR RCTS

NO, NO

NO, NO

MENE

MENE

 

COP Total (E.O)

1 HR RCT

YES

N/A

LEOE

LEOE

 

A/P COP vel (E.O)

2 HR RCTS

NO, YES

NO, NO

CE

MENE

 

A/P COP vel (E.C)

1 HR RCT

NO

NO

LENE

LENE

 

M/L COP vel (E.O)

2 HR RCTS

NO, NO

NO, NO

MENE

MENE

 

M/L COP vel (E.C)

1 HR RCT

YES

YES

LEOE

LEOE

 

A/P COP sd (E.O)

1 HR RCT

NO

NO

LENE

LENE

 

A/P COP sd (E.C)

1 HR RCT

NO

NO

LENE

LENE

 

M/L COP sd (E.O)

2 HR RCTS

NO, NO

NO, NO

MENE

MENE

 

M/L COP sd (E.C)

1 HR RCT

NO

NO

LENE

LENE

 

M/L COP Max (E.O)

1 HR RCT

NO

NO

LENE

LENE

 

COP Area (E.C)

1 HR RCT

NO

NO

LENE

LENE

 

Range of COP AP (E.O)

1 HR RCT

NO

NO

LENE

LENE

 

Range of COP AP (E.C)

1 HR RCT

NO

NO

LENE

LENE

 

Range of COP ML (E.O)

1 HR RCT

NO

NO

LENE

LENE

 

Range of COP ML (E.C)

1 HR RCT

NO

NO

LENE

LENE

 

COP vel (E.O)

1 HR RCT

N/A

NO

NAE

LENE

 

COP vel (E.C)

1 HR RCT

N/A

NO

NAE

LENE

  1. E.0. = eyes open
  2. E.C. = eyes closed LEOE = limited evidence of effectiveness
  3. HR RTC = high risk randomised controlled trial
  4. CE = conflicting evidence
  5. LR RTC = low risk randomized controlled trial
  6. MENE = moderate evidence, no effectiveness
  7. LENE = limited evidence, no effectiveness
  8. NAE = no available evidence
  9. S.I. = stability index