From: Physical activity induced alterations of gut microbiota in humans: a systematic review
OCEBM/ Study design | Age (yrs.) | Study group | Time | Physical activity | Method of fecal microbiota analysis | Diversity indexes, F/B ratio | Fecal results after intervention | Reference | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Phylum/class/order | Family | Genera/Genus | Species | ||||||||
Level 2/ Cross—sectional | 20–45 | Lean (BMI 22.2 ± 2.8) and obese individuals (BMI 35.71 ± 5.11) (M, F), N = 33 | 6 weeks | Progressive training 3 times a week from 30 to 60 min, 60–75% HR | sequencing analysis 1a6S rRNA (V3 region) | Obese individuals: »Beta diversity (PCoA) | * | * | ↑Feacalibacterium spp ↑Lachnospira spp ↑Lachnospiraceae unlassified ↑Roseburia spp | * | [52] |
Level 4/ Case study | 30 or 33 | Ultramarathon or triathlon (M), N = 2 | 6 months | Each individual was trained to the level necessary for participation in an endurance-based sport competition | sequencing analysis 16S rRNA | ↑Alpha diversity (Shannon) »Beta diversity (PCoA) | * | * | * | Marathoner: ↑Vaillonella pervula ↓Agathobacter rectalis Triathlete: ↑Akkermansia munciphila ↑Bifidobacterium longum ↑Methanobravibacter smithii ↓Bifidobacterium animalis | [53] |
Level 2/ Cross—sectional | 18–31 | Students (F, M) Cardiorespiratory exercise (n = 26) Resistance training (n = 26) N = 52 | 8 weeks | Cardiorespiratory: 3 times a week, 60 min, 60–90% HR max Resistance training: 70–85% 1RM, 3–6 sets, 6–12 repetitions | sequencing analysis 16S rRNA (V4 region) | Cardiorespiratory fitness: »Beta diversity (Bray–Curtis, Jaccard, Unifrac) Resistance training  → diversity (Bray–Curtis, Jaccard, Unifrac) | * | * | ↑Prevotella ↑Romboutsia ↑Dialister | * | [54] |
Level 1/ Cross—sectional | 18–40 | Healthy adults, BMI 22–35 kg/m2 (F, M), N = 25 | 8 weeks | Exercise 3 times a week Cardiorespiratory fitness: prospective 5, 7, 10 RTE Resistance training: 70% RM, 3 sets, 8 repetitions, progressive load | metagenomic DNA sequencing |  → Alpha diversity (Shannon)  ≠ Beta diversity (Bray–Curtis) | * | * | * | * | [55] |
Level 1/ Cross—sectional | 20–45 | Overweight and obese individuals (F, M), Control n = 14, Cycling to work n = 19, Exercise I n = 31, Exercise II n = 24) BMI 25–35 kg/m2, N—88 | 6 months | Cycling to work: Exercise I: 50% VO2peak-reserve Exercise II: 70% VO2peak-reserve 5 times a week | sequencing analysis 16S rRNA | Exercise I:  → Alpha diversity (Shannon) »Beta diversity (Bray–Curtis) Exercise II: ↑Alpha diversity (Shannon) 5% »Beta diversity (Bray–Curtis) | * | * | * | * | [56] |
Level 2/ Cross—sectional | Soldiers23.9 ± 1.9 Control: 30.0 ± 8.8 | Soldiers (n = 66) or healthy adults (control n = 38) (M), N = 104 | 8 weeks | Participants lived in the same environment for 8 weeks, ate the same food at regular intervals, and participated in similar training and sleep regimens | sequencing analysis 16S rRNA (V4, V5 regions) |  → Alpha diversity (Shannon, OTU)  ≠ Beta diversity (PCoA) | * | * | * | ↑Bifidobacterium ↑Murdochiella ↓Holdemanella ↓Ruminococcus_2 ↓Streptococcus ↓Turicibacter | [57] |
Level 2/ Cross—sectional | Endurance group 31.4 ± 8.3 strength group 29.9 ± 7.9 control group 33.4 ± 7.9 | Endurance group (n = 13), strength group (n = 12), control group (n = 11), N = 36, (F, M) | 6 weeks | Two groups: endurance or strength exercise, 3 times a week | sequencing analysis 16S rRNA (V1, V2 regions) |  → Alpha diversity (Chao1)  ≠ Beta diversity (Bray–Curtis) | * | ↑Ruminococcaceae | ↑Coprococcus ↑Parasaturella | * | [41] |
Level 1/Randomized trial | 49 ± 4 | Insulin resistance (F, M), (n = 26), N = 54 | 2 weeks | Two groups: First: 30-s exercise bouts of all cycling efforts, Second: 40–60 min of moderate intensity (60% of VO2 peak) All sessions were performed under supervision, 3 times a week | sequencing analysis 16S rRNA (V3-V4 region) | Both groups:  → Alpha diversity (Shannon, Chao1, OTU), ↓ F/B | ↑Bacteroidetes | * | ↓Blautia spp. ↓Clostridium spp First group: ↑Lachnospira Second group: Genus: ↑Faecalibacterium ↑Veillonella Species: ↑Veillonella dispar | * | [58] |
Level 2/ Nonrandomized clinical trial |  > 65 | Sedentary healthy older adults (F, M), Aerobic exercise n = 18, trunk muscle training n = 14, N = 32 | 12 weeks | Aerobic exercise training, brisk walking, at an intensity ≥ three metabolic equivalents Trunk muscle training 1 h weekly | sequencing analysis 16 s rRNA | * | * | * | Aerobic exercise: Genus: ↑Bacteroides ↓Clostridium XIVa | * | [59] |
Level 2/ Cross—sectional | 36.8 ± 3.9 | Women with sedentary lifestyle, BMI > 27.5 kg/m2, N = 19 | 6 weeks | Training 3 times a week with supervision Endurance exercise: weeks 1 and 2: 40 min, weeks 3 and 4:50 min, weeks 5 and 6:60 min | sequencing analysis 16S rRNA (V4 region) |  → Alpha diversity »Beta diversity (Jaccard)  → F/B | ↑Verrucomibrobia | ↑Verrucomicrobiaceae, | ↑Akkermansia ↓Proteobacteria | , * | [60] |
Level 2/ Cross—sectional | Lean 29 ± 2 Overweight 31 ± 2 | Lean: fat mass 21 ± 2% (n = 14), Overweight: fat mass 33 ± 2% (n = 15), N = 29 (M) | 3 weeks | 3 weeks of high intensity interval training | sequencing analysis 16S rRNA (V3, V4 region) |  → Alpha diversity (Shannon)  ≠ Beta diversity (Bray–Curtis) | * | * | * | * | [61] |
Level 1/ Randomized crossover trial | 62–76 | Older adults (M), n = 16, n = 17, N = 33 | 5 weeks | Endurance exercise: week 1: 60% VO2peak, weeks 2 and 3: 70% VO2peak, weeks 4 and 5: 75% VO2peak | sequencing analysis 16S rRNA (V3, V4 region) |  → Alpha diversity (Shannon, OTU)  ≠ Beta diversity (Bray–Curtis, PCoA) | * | * | ↑Oscillospira | ↓Clostridium difficile | [62] |
Level 1/ Randomized crossover trial | 60–75 | Inactive older adults (F) n = 7, N = 14 | 8 weeks | Aerobic and resistance exercise, sessions of approximately 60 min each | sequencing analysis 16S rRNA (V4 region) |  → Alpha diversity (Shannon, Simpson, Chao1) »Beta diversity (PCoA) | ↓Firmicutes ↑Bacteroidetes ↓Clostridia ↑Betaproteobacteria ↑Burkholderiales | ↑Acidaminococcaceae | ↑Mitsuokella ↑Phascolarctobacterium | * | [63] |